The biggest CFB Playoff ranking shock on Tuesday night was Alabama remaining at No. 3. Before the third set of rankings, lots of experts argued that the Crimson Tide should be in the No. 6 to No. 8 range, some argued No. 9 or No. 10, and a couple questioned the Tide's worthiness of being in the top 12.
The Selection Committee was not influenced by the negative chatter. As Hunter Yurachek explained, the committee respects Alabama's Record Strength and Strength of Schedule. The committee has its own set of unpublished metrics for the two data points. How closely their numbers align with the FPI (and other models) SOS and SOR is not known.
The Selection Committee appears to rate SEC conference play higher than any of the other Power Four conferences. The committee's data crunchers measure conference strength along with team strength. Three 6-4 SEC teams ranked shows the committee's respect for the SEC. South Carolina is No. 21, Florida is No. 24, and Ole Miss is No. 25.
Hunter Yurachek on Alabama's Ranking
According to Yurachek, Alabama is top five in both Strength of Schedule and Record Strength, justifying its ranking six spots higher than Tennessee. The Vols dropped one spot to No. 9. Yurachek talked about the Crimson Tide: "Alabama is still top five in record strength, top five in schedule strength, top five in relative offense. And they've won their six SEC games by an average of 22.5 points. Only Georgia is better at 23." Yurachek also credited the Crimson Tide with no letdown against Vanderbilt after the big win over LSU.
It seems this Selection Committee heeded Greg Sankey's offseason demand that schedule strength be given more weight in the rankings. Otherwise, the 10-0 UCLA Bruins would not be ranked below 8-2 Alabama.
In the final three rankings, and especially the last two, for Alabama it's all about seeding. A bye and a home Quarterfinal are within reach.
BREAKING: College Football Playoff Ranking🚨https://t.co/MHjz4nNP7G pic.twitter.com/cGKU4UoZ0I
— On3 (@On3) November 18, 2026

