In a close game, Alabama can ill-afford to be down any players. With Qua Russaw already out of the game with an injury, Tide starting defensive tackle James Smith was ejected in the third quarter following a questionable targeting call.
It was not called on the field, but the booth rang down and ruled Smith had committed targeting upon review. The junior defensive tackle did lead with his helmet, but it did not look like forcible contact and he hit the Georgia running back in the chest - not the head.
Alabama was struggling to stop the run, even with Smith. Now, it just got harder. Alabama fans were justifiably irate on social media following the call that not only sends Smith to the showers for the rest of this game, but will cost him the first half of next week's game against Vanderbilt, too.
See if for yourself:
Targeting against Bama, Smith is out. #GoDawgs pic.twitter.com/XbI8MtBBhe
— Aaron Leicht (@aaronleicht) September 28, 2025
Alabama fans are losing it on social media over James Smith's targeting ejection
Man they are messing up a good football game with this!
— Reggie Ragland (@reggieragland) September 28, 2025
Former players weren't happy with the call on social media, either, if you were curious. I'm not sure what players are supposed to do if that's called targeting.
Man that targeting call is terrible!!!#AlabamavsGeorgia
— Eddie Jackson (@BoJack4) September 28, 2025
Another former Alabama legend sounding off on the terrible call.
We got guys in the booth getting guys ejected that don’t know what targeting is
— Nathan Storey (@Nathan_Storey) September 28, 2025
The worst part is that it wasn't called on the field. The booth rang down to stop the game to make the call. For no reason. In no way is that in the spirit of the rule.
That was a soft ass targeting call @SECOfficiating pic.twitter.com/ripH1y8xRV
— Courtney McKinney (@CourtAnne1225) September 28, 2025
Soft barely even describes it.
Unreal to make that taregting call and affect this game and the next.... just complete shit
— Luke Robinson (@LSRobinson21) September 28, 2025
Not only does Smith's ejection make the sledding tougher for Alabama tonight against Georgia, but it will have a big impact on next week's game against Vanderbilt, too.
That’s so soft. SEC refs are the worst in the business. John McDaid needs to be fired!
— Auburn Jokes® (@TheAuburnJokes) September 28, 2025
Does anybody like SEC refs? Even their families? The officiating in a league that produces as much money as the SEC does just cannot be this bad.
Worst call ever???
— Dalton (@TheNameIsDalt0n) September 28, 2025
I'll stick with the "pass interference" in Knoxville three years ago that directly cost the Crimson Tide the game - and the streak - against Tennessee
That was NOT targeting. Dang.
— Coach GDaddy (@mojorizn1) September 28, 2025
Sure didn't look like it.
Put flags on em and make everybody stop tackling altogether
— 🅱️🅰️Ⓜ️ (@justbam_3) September 28, 2025
This has to be the solution, no? All contact is bad contact nowadays, even when it's not forcible in any sense of the word. What happened to the game we love?
Targeting needs to be done away with. They’ll never apply it fairly. Buffoons.
— White Claw Summer (@JennRollTide) September 28, 2025
There has to be an overhaul of the targeting rule. In the very least, a Targeting 1 and Targeting 2, like in basketball. In no way should what Smith did lead to not only an ejection, but a first-half suspension next week.