Skip to main content

Where Alabama should be ranked Tuesday night and five teams not deserving of being in the top six Playoff rankings

What should happen, but mostly will not, with Alabama and 11 other teams on Tuesday night.
ByRonald Evans
Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports
Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Once the CFB Playoff expanded to 12 teams, it became what Chris Fallica predicted in 2024. Fallica said, "Playoff expansion was never going to increase the number of true title contenders. It was about more games, more fan bases and teams saying they were in the playoff and money."

What the Playoffs are not about is rewarding the best teams. When Alabama was a dynasty in the BCS and 4-team Playoff periods, four teams were usually enough to reward the best teams. Perhaps in a few of those years, a 6-team field was needed to designate real national championship contenders. Never was a 12-team format needed, much less a 24-team one.

The first 4-team Playoff had a primary goal of selecting the best four teams. Selecting the best teams was lost along the way, in favor of the most deserving. Those are very different standards.

Perhaps the pendulum could swing back toward rewarding the best teams, but only with a strength-of- schedule demarcation. The Selection Committee could make a rule that only teams with a top-50 Strength of Schedule (SOS) could gain a top-six seed.

Such a firm rule would never happen, but if it were in place for this season, Wake Forest (No. 55 SOS based on the ESPN FPI), Utah (No. 58 SOS), Texas Tech (No. 68 SOS), UCLA (No. 69 SOS), and Boise State (No. 77 SOS) could not be ranked in the top six on Tuesday.

Just for fun, I used the hypothetical SOS dividing line and ranked teams for Tuesday night. Each team's best win is also included.

Playoff rankings corrections including for Alabama

  • No. 1 - Georgia Bulldogs (9-1) Best win: 20-17 over Alabama - SOS No. 25
  • No. 2 Notre Dame Fighting Irish (9-1) Best win: 31-24 over Miami - SOS No. 47
College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

  • No. 3 Texas Longhorns (6-2) Best win: either 24-23 over Ohio State or 22-21 over LSU - SOS No. 2
  • No. 4 - Tennessee Vols (8-2) Best win 26-10 over Alabama - SOS No. 23
  • No. 5 - Alabama Crimson Tide (8-2) Best win 31-13 over LSU, with an added bump from the 20-17 no-pass interference call loss to Georgia. As much as I hate it, head-to-head gave the Vols the No. 4 nod. SOS No. 6.
  • No. 6 - Indiana Hoosiers (9-1) Best win 27-13 over USC - SOS No. 39
  • No. 7 Miami Hurricanes (9-1) Best win is 36-25 over Duke - SOS No. 27
  • No. 8 Utah Utes (10-0) Best win 28-20 over BYU - SOS No. 58
  • No. 9 BYU Cougars (8-2) Best win is 28-24 over Notre Dame - SOS No. 31
  • No. 10 Wake Forest Demon Deacons (9-1) Best win 30-27 over Louisville - SOS No. 53
  • No. 11 UCLA Bruins (10-0) Best win 17-15 over Oregon - SOS No. 69
  • No. 12 Texas Tech Red Raiders (9-1) Best win 28-26 over Houston - SOS No. 68
Add us as a preferred source on Google