From a position of being more than good last season, the Alabama Football defense can be better in the coming season. Among all FBS teams, the Alabama Crimson Tide defense finished at a credible No. 10 in Scoring Defense last season. Against FBS teams with a winning record, Alabama was No. 3 in allowing 4.62 yards-per-play. National Champion Ohio State was only slightly better at 4.52 yards.
The problem for Alabama last season was when Kane Wommack's defense was bad, it was glaringly bad. The Crimson Tide outscored Georgia, but gave up 519 yards to the Bulldogs. After the loss to Vandy, Alabama legends George Teague and Roman Harper questioned Wommack's scheme. Harper stated that being "brutally honest ...(the Tide's) vision coverage was a failure, lacking eye discipline."
Though the Tide's defense improved in the latter half of the season, Oklahoma's offense out-schemed Kane Wommack's defense, allowing Jackson Arnold to rush for 131 yards.
A second season playing Wommack's system should benefit many Alabama defenders. Based on the talents of individual players, a calculation by Pro Football Focus (PFF) projects the Crimson Tide will be college football's No. 1 defense for 2025. PFF is sometimes questioned for its rating system. In ranking the best defensive teams, it does not consider how schemes will fare against a team's schedule.
According to PFF, college football's best defenses will be Alabama, Texas, Clemson, Georgia, Penn State, Notre Dame, Oregon, Ohio State, Texas A&M, and Texas Tech. PFF's short explanation for rating Alabama Football No. 1 is "Alabama is also the only school in college football that features a top-10 player at every defensive position."
Using Phil Steele's ranking of position groups, the Clemson, Notre Dame, Penn State, and Michigan defenses are ahead of the Crimson Tide. Close behind Alabama in Steele's calculations are Texas and Georgia.
According to a subjective projection by Saturday Down South, the SEC's top defenses are expected to be in order: Texas, Alabama, Georgia, Tennessee, and Oklahoma. According to Steele, the Sooners have the 20th-best defensive back group, but OU is top four for defensive line and linebackers. Steele's analysis does not rate Tennessee as being top five in the SEC.
An Alabama Football Defense at No. 1?
Talent and experience favor the Crimson Tide. Add into consideration depth and Alabama has the potential to be at or near No.1 defensively. To the extent scheme was a problem last season, it is reasonable to believe that Wommack, Mo Linguist, Chuck Morrell, Freddie Roach, and Christian Robinson have made adjustments.
When will Alabama football fans know how good the defense will be? The September date in Athens, GA will be telling. It is possible the Tide's defensive front will prove too much for the Bulldogs' offensive line.