Overreactions happen to the best of us. It's human nature to get frustrated during the course of a game, especially when your team gets off to a bad start.
And boy oh boy did Alabama get off to a bad start in Friday night's College Football Playoff opener against Oklahoma. The Crimson Tide fell behind 17-0 early in the second quarter, and the hot takes were flying.
We'll give some grace to Alabama fans, who had every right to be frustrated, though some of the takes you all threw out were outlandish too (you know who you are).
But the biggest collection of folks who need to eat crow in the aftermath of Alabama's come-from-behind 34-24 win over Oklahoma resides in the national media. The folks who always seem to prey on Alabama's downfall. The sharks were circling during the Crimson Tide's inauspicious start in Norman, and we kept as many receipts as we could.
All the takes proven wrong after Alabama's impressive comeback win over Oklahoma
Alabama well on its way to the most embarrassing postseason performance in school history.
— Kevin Scarbinsky (@KevinScarbinsky) December 20, 2025
We start with what seemed like the general consensus early in the game. I won't give Kevin too hard a time - he wasn't exactly wrong. That 17-0 start with Oklahoma outgaining Alabama 181-12 was about as bad as you can get.
Bye, Kalen. We hardly knew ye.
— Roll ‘Bama Roll (@rollbamaroll) December 20, 2025
This is where we start to branch off into stupidity. Anyone with an Alabama platform spent the last week railing against the national media perception that Alabama fans would want Kalen DeBoer gone if the Crimson Tide lost to Oklahoma in the CFP. It took just over a quarter for a lot of folks to prove that perception right.
Disappointing.
At this stage, not sure anyone at Alabama would mind if DeBoer leaves for Michigan.
— Creg Stephenson the First (@CregStephenson) December 20, 2025
Even more disappointing is someone with a platform like Creg's (AL.com) peddling that nonsense after the rough start. It's one thing for fans to say dumb things in the heat of the moment - I'm guilty of it too - but it's a whole different ballgame when a journalist does.
Is Michigan really sure that it wants Kalen DeBoer?
— Barrett Sallee 🇺🇸 (@BarrettSallee) December 20, 2025
If there's a bad take to be had, you can bet Barrett Sallee is somewhere ready to fire it off.
Who knew the Jake Paul fight would be more competitive than Oklahoma-Alabama tonight
— Brett McMurphy (@Brett_McMurphy) December 20, 2025
Unlike Alabama, at least Notre Dame had the decency to opt out of its bowl game before kickoff
— Brett McMurphy (@Brett_McMurphy) December 20, 2025
Here we have a daily double from the self-proclaimed "America's college football insider" who sent those two tweets out when Alabama fell behind early and then... didn't tweet for the remainder of the game. At least have the decency to show back up and own your horrible takes.
DEFCON 3 I repeat DEFCON 3. Someone check the Michigan message boards Boomer 17 🐘 0. And it hasn’t been that close
— Booger (@ESPNBooger) December 20, 2025
Ass kicking going on right now. pic.twitter.com/ByyqZyHgNC
Just like McMurphy, Booger McFarland fired off this tweet when Alabama was down 17-0 and then didn't say another single thing about the game. People don't even try to hide it anymore.
Alabama tried to tell us who they were in the SEC title game.
— Aaron Torres (@Aaron_Torres) December 20, 2025
We should've listened.
The beaten and battered Alabama we saw in the SEC Championship Game is not who this team is. The resilient team that battled back from the depths of defeat against Oklahoma, though? Yeah, that's who this team is.
This “Alabama” team must be one of those mid-majors that everybody has been complaining about. Dumb as hell that we let them into the Playoff just to get run off the field by the big boys
— Rodger Sherman (@rodger) December 20, 2025
So many folks used Alabama's bad start as fuel for their own narratives. The best rule for watching sports: don't craft wide-ranging opinions using a game that isn't over as the meat of your argument.
The committee would have been fully justified had it determined that Notre Dame was a better team to put in the Playoff than an Alabama team wheezing to the finish line. But it didn’t. And it was probably the wrong choice.
— Dan Wolken (@DanWolken) December 20, 2025
A lot of media members jumped at this take in the first half. Alabama falling behind 17-0 proved it didn't belong in the playoff. Do you have an update, Dan?
Alabama is getting steamrolled by an Oklahoma team that was booed by its home fans in the last two regular season games in Norman.
— Tyler Horka (@tbhorka) December 20, 2025
This is the Crimson Tide team the College Football Playoff committee decided was more deserving of a spot in the field than Notre Dame.
Ha. Haha!
Nailed it, Tyler!
It’s a rout. Oklahoma gonna kill them. DeBoer killed Bama football in two seasons.
— Brandon Walker (@BFW) December 20, 2025
In year two, Kalen DeBoer has Alabama playing in the Rose Bowl. He's done just fine, actually.
Got your tweet you deleted @NicoleAuerbach pic.twitter.com/mhnYKSbyC3
— Christian Sykes (@ctsykes13) December 20, 2025
We'll end with the biggest cardinal sin, particularly for someone with Nicole's platform: if you want to fire off something concrete so early in the football game, don't be a coward and delete your tweet. Stand on it. Accept the heat you are going to get as a result. You earned it.
