Skip to main content

Alabama's Playoff ranking has caused an uproar, fueled by not understanding the Selection Committee's thinking

The Playoff Selection Committee makes it clear why and how it ranks Alabama so high
ByRonald Evans
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

The college football world is in an uproar. As it has been so many times before, the reason why centers on the Alabama Crimson Tide. Alabama's Tuesday night playoff rankings held steady at No. 3. Well-known reporters described the Tide's rankings as a farce, challenged the Selection Committee for bias and favoritism, and Pat Forde wrote that the committee has "made it clear that rules don't apply to Alabama."

Some of the national pundits take every opportunity to slam the Crimson Tide. In this case, most of the college football world appears to think any slam is justified. Many fans, and not just Tennessee fans, are irate. Some have called the committee's actions criminal.

I admit being shocked that Alabama didn't fall a spot or two in the rankings. Still, digging deeper into how the committee members think provides defense for Alabama's ranking.

Start at the bottom of the rankings. Four 6-4 SEC teams show how highly the committee values SEC competition. South Carolina is No. 21, Oklahoma is No. 22, Florida is No. 24, and Ole Miss is No. 25. No other conference has a 6-4 team ranked.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Respect for the SEC is helping Alabama

The Playoff website provides a clue to the committee's respect for the SEC: "New for 2026-27, there is a Strength of Conference Enhancement, which is an enhancement, not a new metric. A similar measure has been available to the committee in the past; this season it's presented with greater emphasis on differences in schedule strength within a single conference."

About Alabama's ranking being higher than Texas and Tennessee, Yurachek said the committee rates Alabama higher for its consistency: "We talked some tonight in our committee room about the consistency of Texas throughout the season, or lack of consistency from one game to the next or within the same game.
We talked about that Alabama has been very consistent in most of their conference games, winning their six conference games by an average of almost 23 points."

The rest of the college football world may hate it, but the Selection Committee has made two things clear. The SEC is viewed as the toughest conference, and Alabama is considered to be the SEC's second-best team.

Add us as a preferred source on Google