Skip to main content

Computer models show that ranking Alabama and other Playoff contenders is harder than it seems

Beyond Alabama and Georgia fans, the CFB Playoff Selection Committee gets little respect.
ByRonald Evans
David Leong-Imagn Images
David Leong-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Apparently, next to watching games, bashing the CFB Playoff Selection Committee is the most fun for college football fans. This season's bashing has largely centered on the committee's rankings of the Alabama Crimson Tide. Maybe only Alabama and Georgia fans respect the Selection Committee and the top computer models.

Every cycle since the CFB Playoff began, the Selection Committee has been derided. Their task is a nearly impossible one and is nearly thankless to boot.

A question should be asked. If the most respected computer models rank many teams differently and in broad ranges, how can the Selection Committee be expected to be more precise?

Alabama and other Playoff Cntenders - Computer Model Rankings

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

I rate Bill Connelly, Jeff Sagarin, Brian Fremeau, Kenneth Massey, and ESPN's FPI as the best computer models. The models vary considerably, showing that correctly ranking every team is nearly impossible.

Georgia at No. 1 is the only unanimous ranking among the five models. Alabama's highest ranking is No. 3 by Sagarin. The Crimson Tide's lowest is No. 6 by Connelly's SP+. The highest and lowest rankings for the Tennessee Vols are No. 7 by Sagarin and No. 11 by the FPI.

There are far greater variations. Massey ranks UCLA No. 9, and the FPI ranks the Bruins No. 25. Massey ranks Utah No. 2. Sagarin ranks the Utes No. 12. Massey ranks Indiana No. 4. Fremeau's FEI ranks the Hoosiers No. 12. Fremeau's FEI ranks Wake Forest No. 4, and Massey ranks the Demon Deacons No. 14. Massey ranks Texas Tech No. 12, and the FEI ranks the Red Raiders No. 27.

At 7-3, the Kentucky Wildcats are likely out of Playoff contention. The Selection Committee has Kentucky ranked No. 16. Massey ranks the Wildcats No. 20, and Connelly's SP+ ranks the Cats No. 42.

Averaging the computer models is not a good solution. So human judgment is needed. And don't forget that the Selection Committee reviews lots of data. Many college football fans may believe the committee does a poor job. But it is unlikely that any group could do better. And the nearly impossible task will be even harder with 24 teams in the field.

Add us as a preferred source on Google