With two regular-season games remaining, No. 3 Alabama (8-2, 6-2 SEC) is firmly in the driver's seat for a College Football Playoff berth. Yet as Kalen DeBoer's squad inches closer to the postseason, a familiar question lingers: Is this roster complete enough to win a national championship in January?
Outside of the double-tinted crimson lenses most fans choose to look through, the skepticism goes even further. Across social media and the college football landscape, plenty of critics argue that the two-loss Crimson Tide are inexplicably ranked inside the top three—and flat-out overrated—sitting ahead of teams with fewer losses and a No. 9 Tennessee team that beat them head-to-head in Knoxville over a month ago.
And according to the man who built six national championship rosters in Tuscaloosa, there is at least some truth to the idea that this team isn't a serious title contender—at least not yet.
Former Crimson Tide head coach Nick Saban made that clear during his Friday appearance on The Pat McAfee Show, leaving the Tide out while drawing a sharp line between programs merely capable of making a deep playoff run and the select few with the "right stuff" built to actually hoist the trophy.
Nick Saban issues blunt but true reality check to Alabama's national title hopes ahead of CFP
"Me personally, I think there are three teams that have the right stuff, and this is no disrespect to Alabama, because I think there's probably seven or eight teams that could win the championship, Alabama being one of them," Saban said. "But, if you're a betting man and you say 'Okay, who can run the ball? Who can play good defense? And who has a good quarterback?' You would say Georgia has that, Utah has that, and Notre Dame has that. Everybody else maybe has a flaw somewhere along the way—now they might be able to overcome it, but I think those three teams have the right stuff."
"I think there's 3 teams that have the right stuff but there's 7 or 8 teams that could win the National Championship..
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) November 20, 2026
Who can run the ball, who has a good defense, and who has a good quarterback..
Georgia has that, Utah has that, and Notre Dame has that" ~ Coach Saban #PMSLive pic.twitter.com/c1osbLlBEE
The crushing part about Saban's assessment is that the harsh truth isn't rooted in outside hate—it's backed up by the exact flaws that have haunted Alabama in stretches all season.
Alabama's run game struggles could be its playoff kryptonite once again
When measured against the three programs Saban singled out, Alabama's vulnerabilities stand out sharply—starting with its disappearing rushing attack. Georgia (207.8 YPG), Utah (223.5 YPG), and Notre Dame (185.7 YPG) all overwhelm defenses with physical backs averaging over five yards per carry. Meanwhile, the Tide sits at just 138.6 yards per game and has failed to crack 100 yards rushing in four straight games—a glaring weakness that prompted former Alabama Heisman-winning tailback Mark Ingram to admit earlier this week that his alma mater "can't run the ball an ounce."
Without a consistent ground game to keep defenses honest, sophomore quarterback Keelon Russell (2,480 yards, 21 TDs) has been forced to carry the offense behind a leaky offensive line. That pass protection breakdown has led to Russell absorbing 28 sacks—nearly double Utah's 15 and vastly more than Notre Dame's three—all while battling an ankle injury and trying to dig the Tide out of recurring slow starts and sloppy execution.
Those offensive limitations have been magnified whenever Alabama has stepped up in weight class, leaving the Tide coming up short against fellow SEC and postseason contenders. While Kane Wommack's defense has held its own against the run, allowing under 95.3 YPG, Georgia's 271.9 total yards allowed per game and Notre Dame's 239.6 mark highlight a level of week-to-week dominance Alabama is yet to master—especially after falling in its two biggest litmus tests against Georgia and Tennessee last month.
That now leaves DeBoer and Alabama standing at a crossroads with Saturday's FCS cupcake matchup against Chattanooga and the Iron Bowl left on the slate.
From here, the final two weeks aren't about surviving—they're about evolving. If the Crimson Tide limp into the postseason relying on a one-dimensional passing attack, slow starts, and poor protection up front, December and January will quickly prove Saban's warning right.
Yet if DeBoer can patch the offensive line, get Russell back close to full strength, and somehow magically get Ryan Grubb to commit to actually finding a spark on the ground, Alabama has more than enough talent to shock the college football universe. With that task in mind, it'll be interesting to see if DeBoer's club has the discipline and overall makeup necessary to morph into a contender who's skilled enough to prove the program's greatest architect wrong.

